
The short answer
HMRC expects you to declare Etsy income once selling becomes a business rather than a hobby, to register for Self Assessment if your trading income exceeds the £1,000 trading allowance, and to register for VAT once taxable turnover passes £90,000. Etsy also reports seller income to HMRC, so the figures on your return need to match the platform data. Our e-commerce accountants deal with this every week.
When a hobby becomes a business
There is no single test. HMRC looks at whether you sell to make a profit, whether you are organised and repeated in your selling, whether you keep records, and whether you have modified or bought stock specifically to sell.
Selling a few unwanted items is not trading. Running a shop with listings, stock, packaging and repeat customers is. The line is usually obvious from the outside even when it feels blurred from the inside. Look at the pattern rather than the label. Occasional sales of personal items point one way. Repeat listings, stock and returning customers point the other.
- You buy materials or stock specifically to sell
- You advertise, use tags and renew listings to drive sales
- You sell regularly rather than occasionally
- You keep records of costs and orders
Registering as a sole trader
Once you are trading, you register with HMRC for Self Assessment. The deadline is 5 October after the end of the tax year in which you started trading. The first return is then due by 31 January, with payment on the same date.
Registration is straightforward and free. The complications come later, when you are deciding whether to incorporate. A sole trader pays Income Tax and Class 4 National Insurance on profits, and the accounts are simpler than a company's. The trade off is not always about tax, because a company also changes how you take money out. Payments on account also catch first year sellers out. If your tax bill passes £1,000, HMRC will ask for half of the following year liability in advance, which can double the January payment. Our guide to sole trader versus limited company covers the comparison.
The trading allowance
If your gross trading income is £1,000 or less in a tax year, you do not need to register or file a return for it. That is the trading allowance, and it applies to gross income, not profit.
Above £1,000 you have two choices. Deduct actual allowable expenses, or deduct the £1,000 allowance instead. You cannot do both, and you cannot claim the allowance against income from a job. For sellers with high material costs, actual expenses are usually better. For sellers with low costs and small margins, the allowance is simpler.
Do not confuse the allowance with the threshold for registration. You can be under the allowance and still need to declare other income on a return.
What you can claim as an Etsy seller
- Materials, stock and packaging
- Etsy listing, transaction and payment processing fees
- Postage, but only the business portion if you also post personal items
- Advertising, including Etsy ads and off platform promotion
- A proportion of home costs if you work from home, calculated on a reasonable basis
- Software, subscriptions and accountancy fees
- Equipment, with capital allowances rather than a full deduction for larger items
Keep the fee statements. Etsy fees are frequently underclaimed because sellers record only the net payout into the bank and lose sight of the gross sale and the fee.
VAT and the £90,000 threshold
VAT registration is based on taxable turnover across all your selling, not just Etsy. If you sell on Etsy, at markets and through your own site, add them together. The threshold is £90,000 in any rolling twelve month period.
Once registered you charge VAT on your sales, reclaim VAT on eligible purchases and file returns under Making Tax Digital. For handmade sellers with low input VAT, registration often means a real price increase, so it needs planning rather than panic. Our guide to VAT on online sales and the VAT returns service cover the mechanics.
The threshold is measured on a rolling twelve month basis, not a tax year. A strong Christmas can push you over in March even when the calendar year looks quiet, so check the total monthly once sales settle into a pattern.
Records to keep from day one
Download the Etsy statements monthly. The CSV exports are easier to work with than the dashboard, and they preserve the detail you will need if HMRC asks.
- Order and fee statements, by month
- Supplier invoices for materials and packaging
- Postage receipts and courier accounts
- Bank and payment platform statements, including any foreign currency conversions
- A record of stock on hand at the year end, if you hold inventory
- Any refunds, disputes and marketplace reserves held back from payouts
Records must be kept for at least five years after the filing deadline. Sellers who download monthly spend an afternoon on the return. Sellers who reconstruct a year spend a fortnight.
If the reconciliation is the part you keep postponing, our e-commerce accountants can take it over without changing how the shop runs.
Where we come in
Most Etsy sellers do not need a complicated structure. They need the fee treatment right, the stock figure right and the VAT question answered before it becomes urgent. Our e-commerce accounting service covers marketplace reconciliations, and bookkeeping keeps the records clean between filings.
Also worth reading: ecommerce accounting, VAT for marketplace sellers and the free VAT registration checker.
Getting the first year right is much cheaper than fixing the third. Talk to us about your shop and we will tell you what actually needs doing.
