[email protected] Yorkshire • Serving the UK
Xero & QuickBooks compatible LinkedIn ↗
Home › Blog › Contractors & CIS

How Do You Claim a CIS Refund?

Published: 22 November 2026 • Reviewed for 2026/27 • By Airstars Editorial Team • 8 min read

CIS refund and deduction statement paperwork

The short answer

You claim a CIS refund by showing, at the end of the tax year, that the deductions taken from your payments are more than the tax you actually owe. For a sole trader that happens through Self Assessment. For a limited company it happens through the monthly PAYE offset and, where there is still a surplus, a direct claim to HMRC.

Nothing is automatic. HMRC holds the money until somebody reconciles it, which is why so many subcontractors leave a refund sitting there for years.

Why deductions are not the same as tax

Under the Construction Industry Scheme a contractor deducts 20 percent from a registered subcontractor and 30 percent from one it cannot verify. That money is treated as an advance payment towards your tax bill, not as a final settlement.

If your actual tax rate at the end of the year is lower than the rate that was deducted, the difference is yours. A subcontractor with modest profits, a lot of allowable expenses or a part year of trading can easily have paid more through CIS than the final liability.

Sole traders: the Self Assessment route

The deductions build up across the year and are entered on your Self Assessment return as CIS tax deducted. HMRC then compares that total with the tax due on your profits.

  • If deductions exceed the tax due, the balance is repaid, usually after the return is filed and processed.
  • If tax is still owed, the deductions reduce what you pay.
  • If you have other income, for example a salary or rental profit, the CIS credit is applied against the total liability rather than just the construction income.

The claim depends on the figures being complete. Missing contractor statements are the single most common reason a refund is smaller than expected.

Limited companies: offset first, claim second

A company does not wait for the year end. Deductions suffered are offset against the company's own PAYE and National Insurance bill each month, which reduces what it pays over to HMRC.

Where the deductions are larger than the PAYE bill, the surplus can be reclaimed from HMRC directly. This is the point where limited company subcontractors most often lose money, because nobody is watching the offset and the surplus quietly accumulates.

What records you actually need

  • Monthly contractor statements showing gross, materials and deductions
  • Invoices that separate labour from materials, because deductions only apply to labour
  • Your own record of every deduction taken, kept as a running total rather than reconstructed in January
  • Evidence of the rate applied, since a 30 percent deduction usually means verification was never completed

If you cannot produce statements, HMRC can still work from its own records, but the burden of proving what was deducted sits with you and the process takes longer.

The 30 percent problem

The most expensive CIS mistake is being deducted at 30 percent when you should be at 20. That happens when a subcontractor is not registered, or when the contractor cannot verify them and applies the higher rate by default.

The fix is registration and verification before the first payment, not a refund claim a year later. Our CIS accounting service handles verification with the contractor so the correct rate applies from the start.

How long a refund takes

Once a correct return is filed, HMRC aims to process repayments within a few weeks, and security checks can add time. A claim built on incomplete statements takes longer because HMRC has to reconcile it first.

If you have unfiled returns or an open compliance check, the refund is usually held until those are resolved. That is another reason to keep the monthly paperwork current rather than leaving it to year end.

Refunds and gross payment status

If you hold gross payment status you are not being deducted at all, so there is nothing to reclaim. Subcontractors who move to gross status partway through a year often still have a refund for the earlier months, which should be claimed in the usual way.

Read more about the application in our guide to gross payment status.

Common reasons a claim goes wrong

  • Deductions entered as a single annual figure with no supporting statements
  • Materials included in the labour figure, which inflates the tax base
  • A limited company claiming a refund it could have offset against PAYE months earlier
  • Returns filed late, which delays the repayment and can affect gross status later
  • Assuming HMRC will notice the overpayment without a claim

If you are not sure what you are owed, the starting point is a reconciliation of the statements against the return. Our payroll and CIS team does that as part of the monthly service.

A worked example

Take a subcontractor with £48,000 of labour income and £12,000 of materials across the year, working for two main contractors. If both deduct at 20 percent on the labour element, roughly £9,600 has been taken at source. If allowable expenses and the personal allowance bring the tax and National Insurance liability below that figure, the difference is a refund rather than a bill.

Now assume one of those contractors never verified the subcontractor and applied 30 percent instead. The extra five percent on that contractor's share is money that should never have left the account, and it only comes back if the statements are checked rather than filed unopened.

Where else the money hides

Deductions are only one place the paperwork leaks. Materials recorded inside the labour figure inflate the tax base, mileage and tool costs go unclaimed, and the split between labour and materials is rarely checked until someone reconciles it. That reconciliation sits naturally alongside bookkeeping and tax preparation, which is why we do them together rather than as separate exercises.

Two related guides are worth reading next: what the scheme is and how deductions work, and whether a limited company suits your day rate.

What to do next

Gather the statements, check the rates applied, and reconcile the total against what your return says. If you would rather someone else did it, get in touch and we will tell you what you are owed before you commit to anything.

WhatsApp Us