
The short answer
You apply to HMRC for gross payment status, and HMRC grants it if you pass three tests: a business test, a turnover test and a compliance test. Once granted, contractors pay you gross with no CIS deduction, which improves cash flow immediately.
Most applications that fail do not fail on turnover. They fail on the compliance test, because of late returns or late payments in the previous twelve months.
What gross payment status actually changes
- No 20 percent deduction on your payments, so you are not waiting a year for a refund
- Cash flow improves by roughly a fifth of turnover on labour
- You still have to file CIS returns if you also act as a contractor
- You still pay tax and National Insurance in the normal way, just not in advance through the scheme
For a growing subcontractor the cash flow effect is often worth more than the tax saving, because the money stays in the business through the year.
The business test
You must be carrying on a construction business in the UK, or a business that includes construction operations. The test looks at what you actually do rather than what your paperwork calls it. A company that supplies labour only can still qualify, but the activities have to be construction operations within the scheme.
The turnover test
The turnover test uses net turnover, which excludes VAT and materials. Published thresholds are currently around £30,000 for a sole trader, £30,000 per partner for a partnership, and for a company £30,000 where there is a single director and shareholder, rising to £100,000 where there are two or more.
Two details matter. First, the figure is net of materials, so a subcontractor with a large materials element can be closer to the threshold than the gross figure suggests. Second, HMRC looks at the business as a whole, not at one contract.
The compliance test, where most applications fail
HMRC reviews the previous twelve months for:
- CIS returns filed by the deadline, including nil returns
- VAT returns filed and VAT paid on time where you are VAT registered
- Self Assessment returns filed and tax paid on time
- Payroll and PAYE obligations where you employ people
A single late return or a payment made a few days after the deadline can fail an application. That is why the sensible time to prepare is six to twelve months before applying, not the week you want the status.
How to apply
Applications are made to HMRC, normally online through the business tax account, and HMRC writes with a decision. If you are refused, you can ask for a review and then appeal to the tax tribunal.
Our CIS accountants prepare the turnover evidence, check the compliance record before submitting and handle the review if a decision goes the wrong way.
Keeping the status once you have it
Gross payment status is reviewed periodically, and HMRC can remove it if you stop meeting the tests. Removal is not rare. The usual causes are a run of late CIS returns, late VAT payments, or a Self Assessment return filed after the deadline.
Because the status affects your cash flow directly, the filers who keep it are the ones who treat deadlines as fixed dates rather than targets. Monthly CIS returns, quarterly VAT and the January Self Assessment all feed the same compliance record.
What to do if you are refused
Read the refusal letter carefully. It normally states which test failed and for which period. If the failure is a single late filing, the review route is worth taking with evidence. If the failure is a pattern, the realistic answer is to fix the process, keep twelve clean months and reapply.
Reapplying too early, without changing anything, produces the same result and wastes another quarter.
Gross status and limited companies
A limited company can hold gross payment status in its own name. The turnover test applies to the company and the compliance test looks at the company's record, including its PAYE. Where a company also suffers deductions before status is granted, those deductions remain claimable as described in our guide to CIS refunds.
Structure decisions and status interact. A sole trader above the threshold may find a company cleaner for other reasons, but the status has to be earned again in the new entity.
What losing status costs
Losing gross status is not a fine, it is a cash flow event. A subcontractor turning over £80,000 in labour goes from receiving the full amount to receiving £64,000 across the year, with the missing £16,000 only coming back through the year end reconciliation.
That is why the compliance record deserves the same attention as the work itself. Late VAT returns, a Self Assessment filed in February instead of January and a run of CIS returns after the 19th all point the same way, and HMRC reads them as one pattern rather than three accidents.
If your record has gaps, the practical route is to fix the process first. Our accounting services cover the monthly filings, tax preparation covers the January return, and both feed the same twelve month record HMRC will look at.
Reading around the subject helps too. Start with how CIS deductions work, then how to claim back what has already been deducted, and finally how IR35 interacts with contractor status.
The monthly discipline that makes it work
None of this is complicated, but all of it is deadline driven. Returns by the 19th, payment by the 22nd, VAT quarters on time, and a Self Assessment return that is not left to 31 January. Our payroll and CIS service exists because that discipline is the part most subcontractors do not have time for.
If you want the status and do not want to manage the record yourself, talk to us and we will check whether you would pass today.
